Find it in your favorite podcast app.
Up until now, my problem in this series has been a scarcity of information. Slaves have existed since the birth of civilization, but they weren’t leaving detailed autobiographies lying around for the benefit of future historians. Their masters weren’t leaving around records on slaves either, because who cared about slaves? It never occurred to them to waste time, ink, a parchment on such a subject.
But all that changes now. With the growth of the abolition movement in the UK and then in North America. suddenly there was interest. It was small at first, but we are no longer dependent on court records and brief mentions in works that are really about something else. Also, far from scraping the Internet for anyone who left enough information to fill an episode, I am now swamped with too many names and stories.
So, everyone from here on out is an African-American, and I am still leaving a lot of out, sometimes because their story is very similar to another that I am telling, sometimes because I’m saving that woman for a future series, and sometimes totally arbitrarily.
Mumbet, Enslaved
Today, our heroine is Elizabeth Freeman. She was born somewhere in the neighborhood of 1744, probably somewhere in Massachusetts. Slaves had first arrived in Massachusetts over a hundred years earlier in the 1630s and had been explicitly legal since 1641. But they were not a huge segment of the population as they grew to be elsewhere. In the mid-18th century only about 2.2 percent of the population were slaves.
At any rate it is in the west Massachusetts town of Sheffield that Elizabeth Freeman grew up as a slave to Colonel John Ashley and his wife. Naturally, she did not have the very suggestive name Freeman at this point, and she is usually referred to as Bett or Mumbet, with either one or two t’s at the end, it’s just not consistent.
Belt wasn’t the only slave in the Ashley household. Her sister Lizzie was there too. There was also a man named Brom. Bett is said to have gotten married, though I can find very little about her husband. Possibly he was a slave there too. Or possibly not. Bett is also said to have had a daughter, named little Bet. And of course, she would have been automatically a slave too by virtue of having a slave mother. One of my sources suggested that Lizzie, the sister, might not really have been a sister, she might have been the daughter. It just really isn’t as clear as we would like. At any rate, there may well have been still more slaves about.
In many slave households the one to fear was the master, but Colonel Ashley was not the reason Bett desperately wanted an escape. He seems to have behaved himself relatively decently, as far as slaveowners go. In this household the mistress was the one to fear. Mrs. Ashley had a violent temper, and in Bett’s words “never overlooked anybody’s wrongdoing but her own” (Sedgwick). The Colonel’s main flaw was that he did nothing to restrain his wife.
Bett was around 40 years old and had lived with the Ashley for almost all her life on the day that she decided this could not go on. Lizzie had cooked a wheat cake for the Ashley family. This is not a sweet dessert like we imagine a cake today. This would have been a major component of a family meal.
Now I don’t know what the slaves were expected to eat for that meal, but Lizzie chose to scrape out the bits of batter from the bowl and cook up a little wheat cake for herself, which seems absolutely reasonable to me, but Mistress Ashley disagreed. She walked in just as Lizzie was popping her teeny tiny little cake into her mouth. Mrs. Ashley yelled, “Thief!” And Bett walked in just as she was raising a shovel from the fireplace, while Lizzie cowered in front of her.
Bett threw herself between her mistress and her Lizzie. And so the red-hot shovel came down on her arm, cutting the flesh to the bone. Bett refused to cover her wound. She displayed it defiantly. People who saw it would say, “Why, Betty! What ails your arm?” and she would say “Ask, missis” in response. She later said, “I had a bad arm all winter, but Madam had the worst of it” (Sedgwick).
Freedom in the Air
Amid the pain and the anger, Bett also found a small glimmer of hope. She had been a slave for all of her nearly 40 years, but it was now 1780 and revolution was in the air. More than just in the air, General Washington had been leading the troops for years now. The war dragged on and on, but plenty of fiery speeches had been made, and some of them had been made by prominent men gathered in the Ashley household where Bett could hear every word.
As far back as 1773, John Ashley had hosted a meeting of 11 men who published the Sheffield Declaration, of which the stated aim was “to take into consideration the grievances which Americans in general, and the inhabitants of this province in particular, labour under.” That declaration “RESOLVED, That mankind in a state of nature are equal, free, and independent of each other, and have a right to the undisturbed enjoyment of their lives, their liberty and property” and “Resolved, That the great end of political society is to secure in a more effectual manner those rights and privileges wherewith God and nature have made us free.”
At some point Bett heard the words of the brand-new Massachusetts State Constitution which a certain John Adams drafted in 1779. It included a Declaration of Rights. It was to be hashed over by the world’s first constitutional convention, with elected representatives from every town in Massachusetts, including Sheffield. It was ratified by them on June 15, 1780, and is arguably the world’s oldest still functioning constitution.
Among many other things, the Adams’s Constitution said:
“All men are born free and equal, and have certain natural, essential and unalienable rights; among which may be reckoned the right of enjoying and defending their lives and liberties” (1619-1819, 48).
Bett, hearing this, made the very logical leap that so many of these men failed to make. She decided those words applied to her, despite the fact that she was black and female and not been born free or equal to her owners.
Suing for Freedom
Bett went to see Thomas Sedgwick, an attorney in town. She told him she wanted to be free, and those words in the constitution said she ought to be free.
Naturally, she had no money to pay. Sedgwick took her case anyway. He was something of an abolitionist. But law cases take time, and naturally the Ashley house would be a rather awkward place to live in the meantime.

Image Source: Wikimedia Commons
So Sedgwick also invited Bett to stay with his family for a while. Now I imagine that if this case had come up in another jurisdiction, it might have been thrown out immediately because as I discussed in episode 4.1, slavery just was. It always had been. Most of the authorities weren’t wringing their hands over it. They certainly didn’t mean for all that give me liberty or give me death stuff to apply to their slaves. Goodness me, no.
But this was Massachusetts and the abolitionist movement was already gaining momentum. As early as 1764, a widely circulated pamphlet said: “The colonists are by the law of nature freeborn, as indeed all men are, white or black.”
On August 21, 1781, the case Brom & Bett v. Ashley came before the Court of Common Pleas. This is not a proud feminist moment, given that Belt was the originator of the suit, not her fellow slave Brom. But Brom was added to the front of the appeal because the last thing Bett needed was a wrangle over women’s rights when the main point was to get her away from Mrs. Ashley. Having a man as the first plaintiff eliminated any possible excuses on that score.
One day later, the jury decided in Betts’ favor. She was free. She and Brom were awarded damages of 30 shillings, plus 6 pounds in court costs. Okay, so good that they got something, but the ratios there are still deeply unsettling. There were 20 shillings in a pound, meaning that court costs were 4 times more valuable than a lifetime of slavery for two human beings.
But at least they won, right? This case was one of several that led to an outright ban on slavery in the state of Massachusetts by 1783. John Ashley did file an appeal, but he withdrew it before it could be heard, probably because he knew that public sentiment was against him.
Elizabeth Freeman, a Free Woman
Meanwhile, what happened to Bett? Well, John Ashley offered to pay her wages if she would come back and resume her work. She said no.
She renamed herself Elizabeth Freeman, which was a richly suggestive last name to choose. But her share of 30 shillings wasn’t going to last long, and there weren’t exactly a lot of other economic opportunities for a woman like her.
However, the Sedgwick family liked her. The Sedgwick children liked her. She stayed with them as a nanny, midwife, and general household help. You might say that sounds very much like what she was doing in the Ashley household, and you’d be right as far as daily chores were concerned. The all important difference was that she was free to leave. And she was paid. And no one hit her with red-hot shovels.
The Sedgwick family were glad to have her for many reasons besides just domestic help. In 1786 and 1787, 4000 rebels protesting high taxes and debt took up arms and marauded the countryside in what became called Shay’s Rebellion. The Sedgwick home was a tempting target, for many reasons, not the least of which was that Sedgwick himself was often away at the capital. On more than one occasion, Bett defended the house. Once by shouting that she would scald any intruders with boiling beer (I’m not making this up, though it’s possible that Catherine Sedgwick was). Once she did it by scaring away the prize mare the men were trying to steal. Once by sitting on her own locked chest while they searched the house for the family valuables, never dreaming that the household valuables would be locked in the servant’s personal chest. Once by serving these uneducated rustics very bitter beer and shaming their ignorance, telling them that this was what gentlemen always drank, if only they were classy enough to know it. Embarrassed, they left (Sedgwick).
Eventually, Elizabeth Freeman saved up enough money to buy her own plot of land. She spent her last years living on it with her children and grandchildren.
We know her story in part from the court records. But also from a more important source. One of those Sedgwick children was a girl named Catherine, who had literary aspirations. She grew up to write successful novels featuring forward-thinking women. She also left numerous letters and a piece called Slavery in New England, which featured her former nanny Elizabeth Freeman.
Catherine wrote about Freeman in glowing terms, with words like “uncompromising honesty” “conduct of high intelligence” “strong love of justice” “iron resolution” “quick and firm decision.” One starts to wonder whether Freeman had any faults at all amid all this heavy praise. We might even wonder whether Catherine was just the type of person who dished out superlatives on everyone, but no, Freeman is the most exceptional person mentioned in all of Catherine’s autobiographical works. So something about her really did make a very favorable impression on this little girl she cared for.
And probably not just on Catherine. When Bett died on December 28, 1829, she was buried in the Sedgwick family plot. She is the only non-family member given that honor. The tombstone they erected said:
“Elizabeth Freeman, known by the name of Mumbet died December 28, 1829. Her supposed age was 85 years. She was born a slave and remained a slave for nearly 30 years. She neither read nor write, yet in her own sphere she had no superior or equal. She neither wasted time, nor property. She never violated a trust, nor failed to perform a duty. In every situation of domestic trial, she was the most efficient helper, and the tenderest of friend. Good mother, farewell” (Browne-Marshall, 49).

Image Source
Up until now in this series, we’ve had next to nothing from the women themselves about how they felt about slavery. Elizabeth Freeman is the first where I can tell you in her own words how she felt.
She said:
“Anytime, anytime, while I was a slave, if one minute’s freedom had been offered to me and I had been told I would die at the end of that one minute, I would have taken it—just to stand one minute. I would have taken it to stand one minute on God’s earth a free woman—I would.” (Browne-Marshall, 49)
If you enjoyed this story, please consider supporting the show to help keep it running. Subscribers on Patreon and Substack can get benefits like the weekly newsletter and bonus podcast episodes and ad-free episodes. If you’d rather do a one time donation on Buy Me a Coffee, that’s much appreciated too.
Selected Sources
The major source for today is Catherine Sedgwick’s 1853 article on her former nanny, Elizabeth Freeman. The full text is available here. The full text of the Sheffield Declaration is also interesting and dripping with irony from the point of view of a slave.
The Massachusetts state government has an article on the abolition of slavery in their state as well as one on John Adams and the 1780 Constitution. The full text of that constitution is available here.
I also used the following articles from JSTOR:
- Browne-Marshall, Gloria J. “1619 to 1819: Tell Them We Fought Back, A Socio-Legal Perspective.” Phylon (1960-) 57, no. 1 (2020): 37–55. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26924986.
- Kelley, Mary, and Catharine Maria Sedgwick. “Negotiating a Self: The Autobiography and Journals of Catharine Maria Sedgwick.” The New England Quarterly 66, no. 3 (1993): 366–98. https://doi.org/10.2307/366002.
- MacEacheren, Elaine. “Emancipation of Slavery in in Massachusetts: A Reexamination 1770-1790.” The Journal of Negro History 55, no. 4 (1970): 289–306. https://doi.org/10.2307/2716174.
[…] escaped slavery, you can see it. Ellen Craft, Elizabeth Keckly, and Harriet Tubman were married. Elizabeth Freeman may have been married; she certainly had a child. That leaves only Harriet Hemings who slipped away […]
[…] we know is that a pregnant 16-year-old Sally came back to Virginia. Last week I quoted Elizabeth Freeman saying that she would have chosen freedom even if she knew she’d die after one minute of it. […]